Reproductive rights: What can we really expect from Fordham?

know about Reproductive rights: What can we really expect from Fordham?

in details

The lack of a statement from Fordham on the reversal of Roe v. Wade shouldn’t surprise

The Supreme Court overturned Roe v. wade in june, and many universities, both religious and secular, issued statements in response. But the Fordham administration remained silent.

For students who don’t check their school email over the summer, or haven’t been closely following reproductive rights news, the lack of a statement may not mean much. Other Rams, however, believe that the lack of a statement in support of student rights is inconsistent with key Fordham values, such as personal carewhich means “care of the whole person”.

Some students hoped Fordham would release a statement criticizing the ruling and supporting reproductive rights for students. However, as Fordham is a Jesuit institution, I do not think we can or should make such demands.

Schools like the University of Michigan and the University of California published statements criticizing the decision and supporting reproductive rights for students, which is to be expected from public universities in blue states. However, it is more reasonable and appropriate to compare Fordham with the response of other Catholic universities.

The president of the Catholic University of America welcomed the decision, saying that the “rejects the profane idea that there is a constitutional right to kill unborn children.” But other Catholic universities including University of Notre Dame, Duquesne University and the Jesuit Marquette University released statements that can be considered neutralciting things like “We must respect each other to move forward with this decision, as we have on other issues that potentially divide us.”

Fordham students would do well to remember that their experience at a Catholic university regarding this topic is not the same as at all other Jesuit colleges due to its location. Louisiana, Indiana and Wisconsin are states where abortion is forbidden or the ban will come into force soon, while Abortion is protected in New York. Statements about the Court’s recent decision are more appropriate for schools in states where abortion is currently more restricted than in New York.

While I don’t think religion should rule our country, what I don’t intend to do is argue with Catholic institutions, Jesuits or any Catholic about their morality and whether abortion is “right” or not, and I don’t think you should either. .

In the state of New York and in the tri-state area, these health services are legal and accessible. Students can expect a statement from Fordham to support others who have lost the right to abortion, but the lack of a statement from Fordham, which aligns the university with the Catholic Church on this issue, can be considered a statement in itself. The most we can expect from a written statement is neutrality and administrative language that tries not to alienate anyone.

See also  A quiver full of racism and anti-reproductive rights – Baptist News Global

There are secular colleges in the United States that, unlike Fordham, provide birth control and rarely abortion services. At Tulane University, they even have sex week, a week of inclusive educational events on sexual and sex-related activities. Some students think Fordham should do the same, and I agree that in an ideal world, the university would provide free condoms and engage in conversations about safe sex. But we attend a Catholic institution, and part of the package is that we can’t expect things that don’t align with the main teachings of the religion. One advantage of being in New York City is that students can access free condoms in many Planned Parenthood either New York City Health locations.

This doesn’t mean the Rams should be content with the decision and do nothing. If you feel angry, this is the time to channel it into caring for others. Abortion is currently protected in New York, but it is an American problem. We must advocate for our peers in other states. exist Several ways you can do this, including donating to abortion funds and independent clinics, voting, and protesting. While I don’t think religion should rule our country, what I don’t intend to do is argue with Catholic institutions, Jesuits or any Catholic about their morality and whether abortion is “right” or not, and I don’t think you should either. .

As a non-Catholic in a Catholic school, there are times when I disagree with university policies and also with individual administrators or professors who dispute these beliefs, such as the decision in question. However, there are several reasons why I think there are better ways to go than arguing in circles with people who have a stronger commitment to the tenets of their faith than I do. the official statement of the Society of Jesus (the Jesuits) on the annulment of Roe v. Wade celebrates the decision, but I encourage anyone who is outraged to read on.

See also  Attorney General Josh Stein continues to fight for women's reproductive rights

“We also affirm our belief that building what St. John Paul II called a ‘culture of life’ requires a stronger social safety net than our country has today,” the statement said. “To be truly pro-life, we must stand with all women, expectant parents, and their children by advocating for policies like universal health care, paid parental leave, and a more equitable distribution of our country’s abundant resources.”

I’m sure many pro-choice people and many Fordham students would agree that our country needs a stronger social safety net. We must advocate for stronger social policies and better distribution of our country’s funds. That safety net is what I think is important to focus on. Instead of creating animosity in a situation where changing the minds of others is extremely unlikely, it is more fruitful to hold the Jesuits accountable for these statements of action. Instead of wasting energy demanding a short statement, we as Fordham students who don’t always agree with Catholic principles should work with them to accomplish the things we both want for the betterment of all Americans.

Catholics, in word, support human life in all its forms. My speech with them is not going to be about whether a fetus is a person or not. It will be about how we can understand each other and work on the things that we both agree on and feel committed to, like abolishing the death penalty, supporting parents, universal health care, supporting children and equitable distribution of resources. I can do all of this while respecting religious beliefs and at the same time advocating democracy instead of a theocracy.

See also  The reproductive rights of incarcerated people matter

Fordham chose not to release a statement on the Roe v. Wade this summer, which is the strongest position we could have hoped for given the university’s history, mission, donors, and administration. Rather than see this as a loss in a place where students are privileged to have the basic right to abortion care, we need to support people in other areas and hold Catholics accountable for what they say they support in other areas. life aspects.